Obama Health Care Fight Mirrors CampaignPresident Revisits Campaign Playbook Tactics in Effort to Beat Back Criticism
Clem's Chronicles: Special Interests/Michael Vick/Enjoy your weekend folks. Here's what's happening tonight: TOWN HALL FRIDAY-President Obama took to the road again today, venturing west to the town of Belgrade, Montana to hear residents’ thoughts and to help explain why his Administration feels that health...
Obama: Be not afraid of health reformby Andrew Zajac
Don't let the venom and bad manners in some of the town hall meetings on health care distract you from the real issues involving the availability and affordability of medical insurance, President Obama told listeners this morning in his weekly radio address.
Obama downplayed the ferocity of confrontations between citizens and lawmakers at a number of gatherings held to assess the national mood for an overhaul of the health care delivery system, saying that beyond "the chatter and noise out there" a serious discussion is taking place.
As he has for several weeks now, Obama sought to keep the pressure on insurance companies, whose practices, he asserted, put health coverage out of reach of too many Americans.
Read on about the debate below the fold, see the full texts below, see the president's address above and Sen. Orrin Hatch's response here:
"I know there's plenty of real concern and skepticism out there", Obama said. But "while there may be disagreements on how to go about it, there is widespread agreement on the urgent need to reform a broken system and finally hold insurance companies accountable."
Obama said reform opponents predictably are using fear tactics to sow doubt about his proposed changes, as they have with previous reform efforts. "Every time we come close to passing health insurance reform, the special interests with a stake in the status quo use their influence and political allies to scare and mislead the American people," Obama said.
In the Republican address, Utah Sen. Orrin Hatch said there's much to fear because Democrats are rushing reform efforts and are trying to fix health care through heedless spending.
"More spending, more taxes, more government is not the answer," said Hatch, complaining that Democrats are proposing fixing a $2.5 billion health care system by shoveling another trillion dollars at it.
Hatch offered a novel twist on the oft-cited statistic that 46 million Americansroughly 15 percent of the country -- are uninsured. That means that 85 percent of Americans do have insurance and are satisfied with it, Hatch said, urging caution lest reform be bungled.
Here are the texts of the president's speech and Hatch's speech:
The president's weekly address:
Saturday, August 15th, 2009
This week, I've been traveling across our country to discuss health insurance reform and to hear directly from folks like youyour questions, your concerns, and your stories.
Now, I know there's been a lot of attention paid to some of the town hall meetings that are going on around the country, especially those where tempers have flared. You know how TV loves a ruckus.
But what you haven't seenbecause it's not as excitingare the many constructive meetings going on all over the country where Americans are airing their hopes and concerns about this very important issue.
I've been holding some of my own, and the stories I've heard have really underscored why I believe so strongly that health insurance reform is a challenge we can't ignore.
They're stories like Lori Hitchcock's, who I met in New Hampshire this week. Lori's got a pre-existing condition, so no insurance company will cover her. She's self-employed, and in this economy, she can't find a job that offers health care, so she's been uninsured for two years.
Or they're stories like Katie Gibson's, who I met in Montana. When Katie tried to change insurance companies, she was sure to list her pre-existing conditions on the application and even called her new company to confirm she'd be covered. Two months later, she was droppedafter she'd already gone off her other insurance.
These are the stories that aren't being toldstories of a health care system that works better for the insurance industry than it does for the American people. And that's why we're going to pass health insurance reform that finally holds the insurance companies accountable.
But now's the hard part. Because the history is clearevery time we come close to passing health insurance reform, the special interests with a stake in the status quo use their influence and political allies to scare and mislead the American people.
As an example, let's look at one of the scarier-sounding and more ridiculous rumors out therethat so-called "death panels" would decide whether senior citizens get to live or die. That rumor began with the distortion of one idea in a Congressional bill that would allow Medicare to cover voluntary visits with your doctor to discuss your end-of-life careif and only if you decide to have those visits. It had nothing to do with putting government in control of your decisions; in fact, it would give you all the information you needif you want itto put you in control of your decisions. When a conservative Republican Senator who has long-fought for even more far-reaching proposals found out how folks were twisting the idea, he called their misrepresentation, and I quote, "nuts."
So when folks with a stake in the status quo keep inventing these boogeymen in an effort to scare people, it's disappointing, but it's not surprising. We've seen it before. When President Roosevelt was working to create Social Security, opponents warned it would open the door to "federal snooping" and force Americans to wear dog tags. When President Kennedy and President Johnson were working to create Medicare, opponents warned of "socialized medicine." Sound familiar? Not only were those fears never realized, but more importantly, those programs have saved the lives of tens of millions of seniors, the disabled, and the disadvantaged.
Those who would stand in the way of reform will say almost anything to scare you about the cost of action. But they won't say much about the cost of inaction. If you're worried about rationed care, higher costs, denied coverage, or bureaucrats getting between you and your doctor, then you should know that's what's happening right now. In the past three years, over 12 million Americans were discriminated against by insurance companies due to a preexisting condition, or saw their coverage denied or dropped just when they got sick and needed it most. Americans whose jobs and health care are secure today just don't know if they'll be next to join the 14,000 who lose their health insurance every single day. And if we don't act, average family premiums will keep rising to more than $22,000 within a decade.
On the other hand, here's what reform will mean for you.
First, no matter what you've heard, if you like your doctor or health care plan, you can keep it. If you don't have insurance, you'll finally be able to afford insurance. And everyone will have the security and stability that's missing today.
Insurance companies will be prohibited from denying you coverage because of your medical history, dropping your coverage if you get sick, or watering down your coverage when it countsbecause there's no point in having health insurance if it's not there when you need it.
Insurance companies will no longer be able to place some arbitrary cap on the amount of coverage you can receive in a given year or lifetime, and we will place a limit on how much you can be charged for out-of-pocket expensesbecause no one in America should go broke just because they get sick.
Finally, we'll require insurance companies to cover routine checkups and preventive care, like mammograms and colonoscopiesbecause there's no reason we shouldn't be saving lives and dollars by catching diseases like breast cancer and prostate cancer on the front end.
That's what reform means. For all the chatter and the noise out there, what every American needs to know is this: If you don't have health insurance, you will finally have quality, affordable options once we pass reform. If you do have health insurance, we will make sure that no insurance company or government bureaucrat gets between you and the care that you need. And we will deliver this in a fiscally responsible way.
I know there's plenty of real concern and skepticism out there. I know that in a time of economic upheaval, the idea of change can be unsettling, and I know that there are folks who believe that government should have no role at all in solving our problems. These are legitimate differences worthy of the real discussion that America deservesone where we lower our voices, listen to one another, and talk about differences that really exist. Because while there may be disagreements over how to go about it, there is widespread agreement on the urgent need to reform a broken system and finally hold insurance companies accountable.
Nearly fifty years ago, in the midst of the noisy early battles to create what would become Medicare, President Kennedy said, "I refuse to see us live on the accomplishments of another generation. I refuse to see this country, and all of us, shrink from these struggles which are our responsibility in our time." Now it falls to us to meet the challenges of our time. And if we can come together, and listen to one another; I believe, as I always have, that we will rise to this moment, we will build something better for our children, and we will secure America's future in this new century.
Sen. Hatch's remarks:
"Hello. I am Orrin Hatch, from the great state of Utah. Thank you for the opportunity to speak with all of you today to talk about the very important challenge of health care reform.
"Ensuring access to affordable and quality health care for every American is not a Republican or Democrat issueit is an American issue. Our nation expects us to solve this challenge in an open, honest and responsible manner. More spending, more taxes and more government is not the answer.
"After the rushed stimulus bill, Americans are rightly concerned about what is being pushed through the Democratic Congress. The rush to pass something that will affect every American life and one-sixth of our economy has raised concerns all around our nation.
"So, why are Americans so skeptical of and concerned with the approach of the Obama administration and Democrats in Congress? A big reason for this concern is that nearly 85 percent of Americans have coverage and they are really worried about what reform means for them. Especially our seniors. And these concerns are moving from kitchen table conversations to town hall discussions.
"I am disappointed about the attempts to characterize the behavior of Americans expressing their concerns as 'un-American'.' Although I strongly encourage the use of respectful debate in these town halls, we should not be stifling these discussions. There is nothing 'un-American' about disagreements. In fact, our great nation was founded on speaking our minds.
"Families are voicing their concerns because they feel like they are not being heard in Washington and I am here to tell you that your voices are coming through and it is essential for all of you to be involved in this issue.
"Republicans in Congress agree with the majority of Americans who believe that just throwing more taxpayer dollars at a problem will not deliver meaningful reform. Telling the American public that the solution for solving a $2.5 trillion health care system is to simply spend another trillion dollars in our current economy, just does not make sense. Especially at a time when spending and debt are multiplying with such alarming speed, like an almost $2 trillion national deficit this year alone, $200 billion in state deficits, a Medicare program on the edge of bankruptcy and a national debt that will triple within the next decade.
"There are several areas of consensus that can form the basis for a sustainable, fiscally responsible and bipartisan reform. These include:
1. Reforming the health insurance market for every American by making sure that no American is denied coverage simply based on a pre-existing condition
2. Protecting the coverage for almost 85 percent of Americans who already have coveragecoverage they likeby making it more affordable. This means reducing costs by rewarding quality and coordinated care, giving families more information on the cost and choices of their coverage and treatment options, discouraging junk lawsuits against doctors and hospitals and promoting prevention and wellness measures like quitting smoking and living a healthier lifestyle.
3. Giving states flexibility to design their own unique approaches to reduce uninsured
4. Empowering small businesses and self-employed entrepreneursthe job-creating engines and lifeblood of our economyto buy affordable coverage for their employees
"Unfortunately, the path we are taking in Washington right now is to simply spend another trillion dollars of taxpayer money to further expand the role of the federal government. The reform proposals being pushed by the Democrats include massive expansions of the Medicaid program and the creation of a new Washington-run plan that will drive millions of Americans from private coverage of their choice into government-run plans. As the federal government's control of our health care system continues to increase, private coverage will continue to decrease, till we are left with a Washington-run and dictated health care system.
"Medicare offers an important lesson. With $38 trillion in future costs, it is facing bankruptcy within the next decade, threatening access to care for millions of Americans. So what is the Democratic approach to fix Medicare for our seniors? Hundreds of billions of dollars in cuts which will be used to expand a financially-strapped Medicaid program and create another government-run plan.
"To enact true health care reform, we should work together to write a responsible, bipartisan bill for the American families who are faced with rising unemployment and out of control health care costs.
"We have a real need for reform and an opportunity on behalf of the American people to get it done. If we are responsible in our policy approaches and strive for true bipartisanship, we can achieve meaningful reform."
